
Kids Rule
At Michael's Body Scenes
New
Cardio Equipment Is Here!
Is
One Vitamin Pill Per Day Enough In Today's...
Why
Women Need Weight Training
Yet
Another Reason To Go To The Gym: How Exercise...
Neck
Strain
Michael’s Body Scenes “All Star Of The Quarter”
YET ANOTHER REASON TO GO TO THE GYM:
HOW EXERCISE CAN HELP FIGHT DEPRESSION
By Kevin Helliker, Wall Street
Journal
Reprinted
from Associated Press - May 10, 2005
Prozac and its competitors have spawned
best-selling books, racked up sales of more than $10 billion
annually and reshaped the clinical treatment of depression.
But an altogether different treatment that
shows tremendous promise in alleviating depression has gone largely
unnoticed. That treatment is exercise. A growing body of medical
literature, including at least three 2005 studies, is showing that
aerobic routines as well as weight lifting are effective at
combating depression. In addition to the famous "runner's high," or
endorphin surge that provides a temporary mood lift following a
workout, the studies show that there is a round-the-clock relief
that sets in several weeks after the establishment of a regular
exercise routine.
A study in the January issue of the Journal of
Preventive Medicine suggested that a half-hour a day of exercise six
days a week - which is the amount the federal government recommends
for all Americans - might be ideal. Comparing two groups of
depressed patients, the study found that the group that performed
only 80 minutes of exercise a week received little to no
mental-health benefit. But the three-hour-a-week group had a
substantial reduction in symptoms. The study concluded, "The
response and remission rates in the (three-hours-per-week) group are
comparable to other depression treatments, such as medication or
cognitive behavioral therapy."
Certainly, the need exists for additional
tools to fight depression. It is a primary cause of suicide - which
is one of the top 15 causes of death - and its burden on patients
and on society is second only to that of heart disease, according to
a U.S. Surgeon General's report. Between 20 percent and 30 percent
of depression patients don't respond to medication after a year of
taking it, says Douglas G. Jacobs, associate clinical professor of
psychiatry at Harvard Medical School.
Nobody, however, is suggesting that depressed
patients need only start running around the block. "I wouldn't say
to anybody that exercise should be at the top of their list," says
Gerald P. Koocher, president elect of the American Psychological
Association. "First, get a good diagnostic evaluation. Then get your
mood stabilized." And then add exercise to other treatments. Studies
have shown that a combination of antidepression treatments are more
effective than a single treatment.
If, as some studies have suggested, exercise
is even remotely as effective as medication, then in some respects
it could be an ideal treatment. It's less expensive than medication
and psychotherapy. It doesn't cause sexual dysfunction or harbor
potentially fatal side effects when combined with other drugs, as do
some antidepressants. Exercise as a mental-health treatment has
dramatically positive side effects: enhanced cardiovascular health
and waist-line management.
But there are also obvious problems.
Mental-health experts usually aren't fitness trainers and have no
way of monitoring patient compliance with a workout regimen.
Moreover, does it make sense to prescribe 30 minutes on the
treadmill to a patient who can barely climb out of bed? It "is
challenging enough for those who are not suffering from depression"
to exercise three hours a week, says Harvard's Dr. Jacobs.
Yet depressed patients who are motivated
enough to get help in many cases might be motivated enough to
exercise on their own. And once they start, studies suggest many
will get hooked. In surveys, people who exercise regularly cite as
its main appeal its mental and emotional rewards. "The most
prevalent reason that people stick with exercise is its effect on
mood," says Andrea Dunn, a doctor of behavioral science whose
research has focused on exercise.
But is anybody telling depressed patients
about exercise? Unlike depression medication - which has behind it
the research and marketing clout of the pharmaceutical industry -
exercise has behind it little research or advertising money.
Consequently, the studies supporting it are typically too small to
win publication in major medical journals. Without any marketing
push, the studies are getting little attention.
Interviews with psychiatrists - medical
doctors whose specialty is mental health - suggest that some aren't
even aware of the body of literature supporting exercise as a
treatment for depression. When the American Psychiatric Association
is asked to provide a psychiatric expert on exercise and depression,
it recommends James Lake, a California psychiatrist who says he
believes his specialty is too narrowly focused on medication.
"Because of collective professional values and
financial interests of academic psychiatry, research priorities have
almost exclusively targeted psychopharmacology," says Dr. Lake.
However, Dr. Lake points out that the association recently created a
committee to research and provide information about alternative
therapies, including exercise.
Psychologists are much more aware of exercise
as an antidepressant. Indeed, psychologists have produced the
majority of the research on exercise and depression. The Web site of
the American Psychological Association features an entire page
describing exercise as a legitimate third leg of treatment, along
with psychotherapy and medication.
Later this month, the annual meeting of the
American Psychiatric Association will feature a seminar called,
"Does exercise have a place in psychiatry?" One of the two
presenters of that seminar isn't a psychiatrist but rather a doctor
of psychology, James Annesi.
The other presenter is a 77-year-old
psychiatrist who years ago deduced from his own running experience
that exercise had tremendous mood-altering potential. The
psychiatrist, Sheldon B. Cohen, also devised a way to get his
patients exercising: He walked and ran with them during
psychotherapy sessions.
Top of Page
Back to Home Page
 |